Sheffield or Sicily? You’ll never know when you’re eating at one of the best pasta places in Sheffield…

1. Butta La Pasta

Butta La Pasta Sheffield
Source: Butta La Pasta website

This London Road Italian has five star ratings for its rave worthy pasta. Although their menu is small, they make up for it with their fresh pasta dishes and personal touch. Visitors love the service and describe the food as ‘bursting with flavour’ so with prices from £10, what’s not to like?

2. The Italian Kitchen

the italian kitchen sheffield
Source: godine

Located in Hallam hub, Eccy Road, The Italian Kitchen offers fresh pasta and pizza with plenty of gluten free and veggie options. It’s a great spot for a celebratory dinner as not only a pasta place but a cocktail bar. Prices are also wallet friendly with pasta starting at £9.50.

3. Kia’s Pastaria

Kia's Pastaria sheffield
Source: Kia’s Pastaria Facebook

This restaurant specialises in pasta and it earns its title as one of Sheffield’s top restaurants. The specialist menu is short but sweet with options diners love, like the seafood pasta. The authentic venue pays great attention to detail so you know you’re getting the real Italian experience.

4. Nonna’s

Nonna's sheffield
Source: godine

Nonna’s is located in the heart of Eccy Road and boasts a large menu featuring authentic Italian food. You can enjoy the atmosphere of Eccy Road from the balcony, which has heaters for the winter cold. Nonna’s is also a wine bar so you can pick the right vino to compliment your food.

5. Olive

Olive Sheffield
Source: Olive Facebook

If you’re looking for fresh, delicious, Italian food, Olive is a great choice. Customers love the friendly atmosphere and excellent service with one review saying it ‘must be the best mediterranean in Sheffield!’. This restaurant was also named the most romantic restaurant in Sheffield, so you know where to take your next date.

A few places that deserve honourable mentions include Mama and Leonies, La Gondola and VeroGusto so if you love pasta, you’ll love Sheffield too.

Last Updated on January 24, 2024